
The recent appeal surrounding the Caddo Parish sheriff race has reached a resolution. The 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld the prior ruling, denying Henry Whitehorn’s appeal. The initial decision mandated a new election following the November 18 runoff, where Whitehorn secured victory over local attorney John Nickelson by a mere one-vote margin.
Whitehorn tallied 22,621 votes against Nickelson’s 22,620. However, Ad hoc Judge Joe Bleich confirmed the presence of at least 11 illegal votes. This finding led to the determination that the election outcome couldn’t be accurately ascertained.
Whitehorn faces a decision on whether to petition the State Supreme Court. The ultimate resolution lies with the high court, which may either agree to review the case or dismiss the request.
The appeals panel, comprising five judges, extensively reviewed the case’s arguments and interrogated both sets of attorneys before deliberating. Per state law, rulings on such election disputes must be issued within 24 hours, adhering to this timeline in this instance.
Judge Bleich’s prior ruling highlighted the existence of at least 11 illegal votes, rendering the determination of the election winner unfeasible. Consequently, he mandated a new election.
If a new election is conducted, it’s anticipated to coincide with the Presidential Primary on the March ballot.