Move over Siskel & Ebert! A review of Fifty Decembers: The History of the Independence Bowl

One of the things I never signed up for as a journalist was to be a film critic. But here we are, well into Decade No. 5 and it looks like it’s time to branch out.

I was among those who were in attendance Thursday night for the premiere of Fifty Decembers: The Story of the Independence Bowl and if I’m going to make my debut as a critic, at least it was something right down my alley.

For two reasons.

One, I’m proud to say that I was in the stands at the very first Independence Bowl. There’s a long and somewhat-comical reason that got me there, but I was posted up in my high school letter jacket to watch McNeese State and Tulsa battle it out. (Mainly it was something to do on a Monday night.)

Two, I recently produced a documentary that was along similar lines (a football retrospective) and therefore I was a lot more interested in the production of this feature than I might have otherwise been.

But you didn’t come here for discussion about colorization or audio mixing.

Documentaries come down to one thing – telling the story.

There’s no way to do a comprehensive game-by-game look at the bowl history unless they started handing out sleeping bags by the time the film got to Ole Miss making its third I-Bowl appearance.

So they had to pick and choose the highlight. I have some quibbles about a few of the omissions – more in a moment – but for the most part, it gave an in-depth look at the significant moments: the Snow Bowl, Nick Saban coaching against LSU, the Notre Dame-LSU game and a few others.

All of those stories – especially the Texas A&M-Mississippi State snowfest – were very well told. Great perspective from a lot of different angles.

Two things really stood out to me that were particularly well done. The vintage footage that the producers came up with was amazing. I was constantly asking myself “how did they get that?” Combing through all of that is an arduous task. It doesn’t just fall into place; it is the definition of tedious work.

The other impressive aspect was the number of contributors who were involved. I know they didn’t get everybody they wanted, but getting Daniel Jones at Colts training camp plus Frank Beamer, David Cutcliff, Mack Brown, Kevin Faulk, Abram Booty and many more was some serious want-to.

Perhaps the most impressive interview was the least recognizable. When Terry McFarland, quarterback of the McNeese team that played in the first game in 1976, showed up on the screen, that’s a hat tip for whoever came up with the idea to go that far back in the archives.

OK, now a few quibbles.

There were three games/moments that I thought were significant that were brushed over and/or left out. (And I do understand that good stuff ends up on the cutting room floor, even though with digital that’s no longer a thing.)

I thought the absence of the bowl game in 2020 due to Covid-19 was a big story. Yes, other bowl games suffered the same fate as well, but what were some of the decisions that went into that? Was there concern that it might not come back?

The 1991 game between Georgia and Arkansas was also huge for multiple reasons. It was Arkansas’ “unofficial first game” in the SEC (they had just been admitted but didn’t start playing in the conference until the next year), plus it was on ABC. A real, major network was carrying the Independence Bowl matching up two significant college programs. Only three years earlier it had been Southern Miss and Texas-El Paso on the long-forgotten Mizlou Network. The 1991 game was a huge step up.

There was another step up 10 years earlier that played a big role in the game’s history and was a storyline that probably could have gotten more play. The 1981 game (Texas A&M and Oklahoma State) and the ’82 game (Wisconsin vs. Kansas State) brought about a lot of local discussion because the bowl was now taking teams with lesser records in exchange for more eyeballs. The bowl had gotten out of the Southland Conference business and was willing to get teams that would sell tickets as well as make the bowl less regional and more national.

Among the 9-2 teams that didn’t get an invitation in 1981? The Miami Hurricanes (two years away from a national championship).

As the doc was making its way through, I became curious as to how it was going to end. With chronological pieces, there’s always the temptation to get to the last event and just stop. But you must find a way to bring it all home and I thought one of the best things that was done was to let the legendary coaches – none of whom live anywhere near here – give their thoughts on what the Independence Bowl is all about.

We have our perspective because we see it every day.

Their perspective is what the college football world sees.

Contact JJ at johnjamesmarshall@yahoo.com