Five of seven local teams hit the road in second round, starting with Shreve tonight

GATOR GATHERING: Captain Shreve coach Jeremy Wilburn confers with his quarterbacks Kenneth Matthews (17), Jaylen Houston (10) and starter Maddox Parrot (wearing helmet) during the Gators’ 61-48 comeback win over Parkway. (Journal photo by KEVIN PICKENS)

By MATT VINES, Journal Sports

When New Orleans teams that share football stadiums put enough high-seeded schools in the second round of the playoffs, you play a Thursday game.

That’s what happened to No. 15 Captain Shreve (6-4) as the Gators head down to No. 2 Jesuit (8-2) in the second round of the Division I Select playoffs.

Jesuit is one of three schools that will host in ancient Tad Gormley Stadium, starting tonight at 7 p.m. and continuing Friday at 3:30 p.m. (No. 8 Brother Martin hosting No. 9 Bonnabel) and Friday at 7:30 p.m. (No. 1 St. Augustine welcoming in No. 17 Holy Cross).

The Gators are the only non-New Orleans school in that six-pack, further showcasing the clout that the state’s biggest city possesses when it comes to the gridiron.

Captain Shreve is one of seven Shreveport-Bossier teams still in the mix with five of those squads hitting the road in the second round.

The Gators have been on both sides of second-round coin when it comes to high seeds and travelling.

Captain Shreve battled No. 4 seed Catholic in a 37-14 loss in 2025, the fourth time the Gators have lost in the second round since the playoff brackets split into select/non-select across the board in 2020.

The Gators have been the road dog twice but also the No. 2 seed and home team twice – but all four games resulted in losses.

As the No. 2 seed, Captain Shreve has dropped contests to No. 18 Archbishop Rummel (13-3 in 2023) and to No. 18 Parkway (30-23 in 2021).

Now the Gators will try to reprise that role and advance to the quarterfinals for the first time since 1983 – almost as long as its first (and only) state championship in 1973.

Jesuit brings a more storied football history with eight total state titles, but only one (2014) since 1960.

The Blue Jays are looking for their first quarterfinals trip since playing for a state title in 2021, and Jesuit rolls into the playoffs on the heels of consecutive victories against John Curtis, Rummel, and Edna Karr.

Loyola, Calvary at home

Loyola and Calvary will start their Division III Select playoff push in the second round at home, but the opponents are much different.

The No. 8 seed Flyers (7-3) catch a Dunham bunch (7-3) quarterbacked by five-star Alabama commit Elijah Haven.

The No. 5 seed Cavaliers (9-1) will welcome in a Baker (10-1) squad that’s having a resurgent season coming off three wins in 2025.

Baker played just two playoff teams on its schedule, and its first-round win was a repeat victory over Helix Mentorship Academy (41-0).

The Buffaloes are a nice story, but Calvary Baptist won’t be in a story time mood as the Cavs are aiming for a return to the Division III Select title game.

That Dunham program beat Calvary for the title in 2025 and has played for state championships in each of the last two years.

A 2-3 start included a 55-15 win against Parkway in which Dunham pulled away in a massive second half before Dunham dominated its district with four of five wins by 49 points or more.

Loyola is no stranger to tough tests on their own home field as the Flyers battled eventual state runner up Archbishop Shaw (lost 38-7, without quarterback Bryce Restovich) in the 2025 quarterfinals.

The Flyers will get a state-title like test in the second round this year as Loyola is aiming for the quarterfinals for just the second time since 2019.

Other road dogs looking for upsets

Five Shreveport-Bossier teams are packing their bags this week.

How many upsets can local teams pull?

Division II Select: No. 9 BTW-Shreveport (8-3) at No. 8 BTW-New Orleans (7-2)

The Shreveport version of the Lions (yes, both BTWs have Lions as mascots) is a slight underdog as a No. 9 seed (8-3) headed to No. 8 seed BTW-New Orleans (7-2) in Division II Select.

The cost of being the lower seed is a 330-mile trip to Joe Brown Football Stadium located in New Orleans’ extreme northeast corner.

One important distinction – Shreveport’s BTW plays in a Class 4A district with reputable opponents like North DeSoto, Northwood and Minden.

BTW-New Orleans hails from District 10-3A, which features a blue blood in district champion De La Salle but not many other proven entities.

The district does still have three teams alive in the playoffs, although the one that won a first-round game beat another New Orleans school without much of a history.

Another measure – the New Orleans bunch is 2-2 against playoff teams while Shreveport BTW is 3-3, including the first-round win against McKinley (46-6).

Division I Select: No. 12 Evangel (6-4) at No. 5 Archbishop Rummel (7-3)

Well, it could be tougher.

Evangel’s district title win against Haughton meant that the Eagles avoided the top four seeds (St. Augustine, Jesuit, Edna Karr, and Alexandria) for another round.

But Rummel doesn’t provide any comfort as their three losses have come to Karr (27-20), Jesuit (37-33) and St. Augustine (35-22).

Rummel does have wins against University Lab, Archbishop Shaw, John Curtis, and Brother Martin as feathers in their cap.

Evangel and stud quarterback Peyton Houston have challenged themselves against the likes of West Monroe, Neville and Cornerstone Christian in losses, but their best win came against that eight-win Haughton squad.

The Eagles broke through the quarterfinals barrier this past season after three straight second-round losses.

This is a quarterfinals-type obstacle in Round 2.

Division I Non-Select: No. 11 Haughton (9-2) at No. 6 Destrehan (9-2)

Speaking of breaking through, Haughton returned to the playoffs for the first time since 2022 and outslugged Parkway in a 47-46 victory that culminated in a two-point conversion stop.

It’s the first playoff victory since a No. 27 Haughton squad knocked off No. 6 Airline in that 2022 appearance.

Destrehan knows that sting as the No. 3 seed Wildcats lost to eventual 2025 state champion Ouachita in the second round.

But it’s a program accustomed to deep playoff runs, like its 2024 semifinals trip.

This past season was the first time Destrehan didn’t make at least the quarterfinals since 2017, which included a 2022 state title and a 2019 runner-up.

Haughton’s last quarters appearance? 2019 when they ran to the semifinals and lost to Destrehan (27-17).

Division III Non-Select: No. 12 Green Oaks (8-2) at No. 5 Marksville (9-2)

Can the Giants keep the magical season going and add to their playoff win total?

Green Oaks handled Donaldsonville in the first round, 32-14, its first playoff win since a 2020 forfeit by Marksville and just the seventh all-time in program history.

There will be no forfeit Friday as the Tigers are aiming to build on their second straight second-round appearance.

Green Oaks has just its second-winning season since 2001 (the other came in 2020).

And the list of wins is credible as well, which includes a BTW squad that nearly earned a bye in Division II Select and playoff teams in North Webster and Donaldsonville.

Marksville is forged by the fire that is District 3-2A as the Tigers have a host of games against playoff competition, which includes wins against Catholic-Pointe Coupee, Avoyelles and Erath with a near miss against Jena (36-30).

The Week 10 loss to Bunkie (50-8) was out of character, but Marksville recovered with a first-round defeat of No. 28 Rayville (42-20).

Contact Matt at matt.vines@lsus.edu